I really wanted to like this. I ordered the 2B CC cream in my last order and it's great. But I now know these kinds of eye primers DO NOT work on oily lids (I also tried an ELF cream stick primer which was useless, too). It feels like a lip balm, very slippery, but dries quick and it's almost like you have nothing on. The shadow application was great but within a couple of hours, all my eye makeup was mostly worn off. So for anyone who had oily lids, this stuff does not work.