I'm kind of in love with this quad. I quite seriously ran (as in, the same day) right after watching Samantha Chapman (Pixiwoo on YouTube) do a tutorial on a back to school look for her Real Techniques channel using this quad, and I fell in love. I just had to have it.
For $25, I think it's priced fairly, and is in very nice packaging. I don't LOVE the packaging, but it's SO much better than the ugly, old lady green compacts they used to have. I haven't seriously considered a Clinique product in so long because I honestly hated the packaging and was under-whelmed by the products. But I love this Black Honey line.
I first do have to say that I'm warm-toned, and this collection is definitely best-suited for warmer-toned people. I think I was especially excited because I really wanted the Prelude quad that Chanel recently launched in their Fall collection, but the colors didn't work on me because they were cool-toned. This one was perfect and like half the cost. Anyhoo ...
These shadows are lovely and work so well together. The whole collection works amazing together, actually. It all compliments everything without being too matchy-matchy. The shadows have two shimmery shades and two matte ones. The lighter matte shade is a great highlight or base, and the other is a great crease color for a very natural look. The two shimmery shades are stunning, especially the darkest color.
Overall, I'm very, very happy with this quad. Perfect for fall and I'd recommend it to anyone.
For reference, I'm also very fair and have green eyes, and I think these colors look best of fair skin.