Since I love experimenting and trying out new products, I rarely do repeat purchases of a single product over and over again, but I've made an exception for this eyeliner. Truth is, although CoverGirl has marketed this as an eyeliner, they should have marketed this as a brow-pencil instead, because it's the bomb-diggity.
I'm Asian with an olive-based fair complexion and I've tried countless browns, near blacks, and taupes for my brows. I've had so much trouble trying to find a pencil that doesn't make my eyebrows look drawn in (as much as that may be the truth). BUT THIS IS THE ONE, GUYS. THE ONE. It makes my eyebrows look like THE TRUTH.
What I makes this product so genius is its color. The warm, almost-brownish grey is so natural when applied with short, light strokes on your brows. I could see this color being very flattering on those with cool-toned hair: ashy blonde, chocolate brunette, and deep brown/black.
One problem though, the packaging seems a bit faulty. If the pencil twist-up mechanism becomes broken, no product comes out. And it's such a bummer. I'm working on trying to take apart my first pencil, but I've bought a spare in case. Still, you MUST try this pencil out. It'll save your brows.