In spite of myself not being fond of the brand or its owner, I picked up this palette from Dollskill after returning an item for store credit (apparently they don't give refunds). It is a really nice palette, with beautiful packaging, in traditional Lime Crime style. The shimmer shades are less pigmented than the mattes, but I wasn't too disappointed because I'd gotten it for the matte shades, and both shimmers (Aura and Shell) work well over a cream shadow base (I use the Maybelline Color Tattoos). Aura especially is nice as an inner corner highlight. The mattes are gorgeous and very pigmented, the only thing I will say is while Divine appears to be a warm taupe/gray shade in the pan, it becomes more of a mauve-y shade on my eyelids (skin tone NC30/35-ish), but its still a very pretty color and my go-to for my crease. I'm not sure if I could convince myself to put more money in Doe's pocket once I use up these shadows, but (unfortunately..) it really is exactly what I was looking for in a neutral palette: warm, matte shades with more variety than just eight shades of brown.