There's a lot that I really like about this eyeliner--it is so soft and pigmented and easy to apply, and it can easily create a variety of looks (tightlining, waterlining, regular lines, smoky, etc). However, and the reason that I give it a 3 and won't be buying again, is that it smudges so much for me (so much!). I can't get it to last all day, and it just gets everywhere. At the same time though, I have trouble getting it off completely at the end of the day. I do have oily eyelids though (so oily. Sometimes urban decay primer potion creases on me), so if you have normal oily production, you will probably love this because otherwise it really is a lovely product!