I have and love the stila stay all day in black, but these colored ones are so horrible that i did about 7 double takes. I have 4 colors that i got for a costume: white, periwinkle, emerald, and turquoise, and i've never regretted anything more.
They are SO sheer - its like that dirty diluted water you get when cleaning paint brushes. I built up about 4 layers, letting them dry completely before layering, because it would move on itself otherwise. Then, after all this work and frustration, it fades in about 2-4 hours. And $20 for this misery? Hell no.