Over the years, my go to eye primers have been the original UDPP as well as MAC's Paint Pot in Painterly. I still love both of these products, but haven't repurchased the UDPP because I still have a decent amount of product left in the paint pot, and I wanted to try one of their new primers. I also have UDPP in Sin, which I like when I'm doing a shimmery look, or just want some shimmer on my eyes, but I do not reach for this product that often. I think this is simply because shimmer isn't something that I go for often.
So since that background information about what I already use, I must say that I am a fan of this new primer. I love neutral matte, that's definitely more my thing, and I truly believe that this fits the bill. I do set it with whatever lighter powder I'm using, or I wait for it to dry. My eye shadow looks exactly the same as when I first applied it in the morning. A definite keeper and sad that's it's a limited edition.