This is a review for the latest long wear pencil. This is not long wear and after 2 hours smudged badly. With these things, its either a zero or a five rating, this is closer to zero. If its not smudge proof then the product has not sufficiently met its purpose and is deemed useless. Pls try before you buy. I prefer the clinique pencils in the wind up, they are much better in terms of performance. This was not a pretty sight and I felt the average drugstore pencil is better.